First and foremost (even though this is now old news), I need to address how monumentally proud I am to have voted for President Barack Obama in the last presidential election. While I have not agreed with everything he and the government have done during his tenure, his public support of loving relationships, whether they be between a man and woman, two women, or two men, was truly a momentous occasion. I was raised to love and cherish all people, even when it's difficult, but I know not everyone shares my views on the subject. Affirming that same-sex marriages should be legal was a big risk for him as a politician and candidate for re-election as president. As long as it is a true measure of how he feels towards the issue, I applaud him. You can hear his statement on NPR.
As a Connecticut resident and prospective teacher, what concerns me in politics is this Education bill that Governor Malloy just passed. The bill is daunting at best, and filled with lawyer speak that this humble English major definitely struggles with. I am still attempting to sift through the information I can gather about this particular piece of legislation that will affect my career in the future. If anyone has thoughts about this, please comment, because honestly my head is still spinning and I don't think I can intelligently comment on this until I can ground myself again.
Everyone has thoughtsabout the world around them. This blog expresses the variety of thoughts I have on issues ranging from politics to education to movie reviews. I try to be fair in my thoughts. I will never use the real names of people in those situations I take from my own life, for the benefit of keeping their anonymity, but I will comment on a plethora of experiences and causes that I find important to talk about. Follow me if you like what you see!
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Friday, May 18, 2012
Friday, March 30, 2012
A Reflection on Educational Reform.
I was going to refrain from commenting on my recent endeavor to find out more about educational reform in my home state of Connecticut, because in many ways I am no expert on the subject. However, I feel able to make a few comments based on a Q & A session I witnessed regarding Governor Malloy's proposed bill. This bill, from what I have gathered, mostly deals with updating and changing the teacher evaluation protocol, making teachers accountable in a variety of ways (test scores, evaluation of student progress, observations of teacher performance, peer/parent review, and whole-school progress). Without the percentages, this seems a mostly fair evaluation of teachers (but again, I am no expert and am only beginning to learn about this bill). However, as a prospective teacher who will (hopefully) have a full-time teaching position in the fall, I do have a few concerns regarding this breakdown.
For one thing, standardized test scores of a teacher's students count for 22.5% of the total teacher evaluation. Considering this alone counts for nearly a quarter of a teacher's evaluation, and probably contains the most amount of uncontrollable factors on the teacher's part, is that high percentage reasonable? As I have never taught in my own classroom, I cannot be entirely sure. I do have reservations about it, though. For one thing, on the day of the test, there are many factors out of the teacher's control that can affect student success, such as hours of sleep the student received the night before, whether or not the student had a balanced breakfast, and the testing environment a student is placed in (especially for tests like the SATs). These things can affect student focus and their cognitive functions. If their basic needs, such as food and sleep, are not met, their performance on other tasks is already limited in success (Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs).
Another concern I have regarding the governor's answers to questions at this meeting was his dismissive attitude toward concerns of poverty in certain districts. His answers to concerns of educators and parents regarding the effects of poverty on student performance were that within each of the most "troubled" districts, there was at least one "successful" school (paraphrasing here). Well, in a district that has more than 10 schools, one successful building does not instill me with a sense of hope. In my grad school classes, we have discussed at length the degree to which change is possible within education without changing the society that education exists within first. Every conversation has ended in a consensus that schools reflect society, and so society must be the first to change. So, his response does not really answer the question.
From my response above, you may think I do not support our governor in his endeavors to improve education. In fact, I applaud his efforts to make education better, because it is true that just 20 years ago, Connecticut was the #1 state with regards to education, which is no longer true and in fact we are in danger of dropping out of the top 10 states. I merely want to reflect on some of the reservations I have regarding where the state government's efforts are being concentrated.
I will admit two things I am especially interested in seeing succeed within this bill. I am intrigued by the idea of more "individualized" professional development for teachers. I am looking forward to seeing how this is executed, as everyone (teachers and students alike) has different skills and levels of mastery. A more individualized development for teachers will mean that teachers can get the support they need in the areas they need it most, instead of sitting in a large lecture hall while someone imbibes information. Also, I am interested in this notion of an improvement of communication between agencies (police, schools, DCFS, etc.) that are involved in student cases, so that all agencies have complete and accessible information. After all, communication is one of the most important skills you learn in school, and the "hidden curriculum" shows students how the world around them operates. If they see that communication between parties that have some kind of connection to themselves is limited and unsuccessful, that is how they will learn to communicate.
Well, enough of my rantings about this issue. I think I've gone on long enough. I only hope that the changes made will be for the benefit of our students, as they are our first priority.
Friday, March 9, 2012
Feeling a little political...
I don’t pretend to be the most politically aware person in the world. Nor do I pretend that most of the time I’m not caught up in my own busy life. I know there is no way to be aware of everything that happens in the world, but if this morning has done anything, it has made me more aware of my own ignorance and hypocrisy.
As a pre-service teacher, soon to become certified, I have often talked to students about being critical and being aware of the world they live in beyond the walls of their homes and their schools. And yet, have I done this myself? No. I have been ignorant to many things that have been unchallenged for years. This hypocrisy is inexcusable.
The U.S. is often criticized for being self-centered and greedy. Perhaps that is how we have managed to maintain our “superpower” status. I’ve been out of the loop so long, I’m sure I have nowhere near the amount of information necessary to make that accusation. However, I have noticed the way in which many people in my own life (myself included), forget to be human.
I’m not one for making pledges and promises when I may not be able to keep them. However, my eyes are a little more open than they were yesterday.
Here is something I know for sure:
At their core, human beings are emotional, but in recent generations the expression of raw emotion has been frowned upon and deemed “uncivilized.” Due to this, people have forgotten the power and beauty in emotion. We have forgotten our consciences and our instincts.
However, we have not completely forgotten these emotions. No, we have only suppressed them or internalized them so that we are not embarrassed by them. Lately, I’ve come to believe a little embarrassment is good for the soul. I found this out yesterday in a rather surreal moment of my own life.
Let me explain.
I am currently a Graduate student, working toward a M. Ed. in Curriculum & Instruction to gain certification in Secondary English. I am in my final semester, during which I have to complete an Inquiry Research Project. Yesterday, I had the class that pairs with this project that is supposed to teach us how to research, collect data, and analyze that data. For the past three classes (which are each 2.5 hours long), our professor has spent (wasted, rather) our time by going so in depth into the concept of focus groups (introduction, mock focus group, and analysis of focus group data), which less than 10% of the class is using.
Note: PREVIOUS to these classes, the class banded together and formulated a list of our most pertinent needs and concerns regarding this class and wrote her a collective email expressing them. She never addressed our concerns. She merely shrugged them off by saying, “You have to trust me.”
Anyways, back to the point. This fateful day, I am sitting in class, on facebook because the first 40 minutes have all been explicit instruction on how to edit a table in Microsoft Word, which felt intellectually insulting as someone who has been using this program since Middle School. My colleagues in class were discussing on our class group the audacity of this woman to spend 40 minutes going over something that we could have taught ourselves in 5. I posted saying, “I feel like I should say something.” It only took two responses of “DO IT” for me to raise my hand, interrupt, and proceed to ask the professor if there was a simpler, more succinct way of going over this, because many of us were already familiar with the concept. I suggested that maybe it would be more prudent to hand out an example of what the correct formatting is and then differentiating by taking those who needed additional help aside in a small group and assisting them in the more elaborate instruction she had been giving.
Her response: I will be done in 5 or 10 more minutes.
The result: The director of our program, whom we had left out of the conversation out of respect for his position and the belief that she would work with us if we presented our concerns, was notified of the gravity of the situation by phone calls, email, and the like, from several people. Before the end of yesterday, appropriate action had been taken to ensure that our concerns were met and taken into account.
This is a prime example of change only being possible if one person starts to make it happen. Was it embarrassing for me to have to call out the teacher in the middle of her class on her poor teaching methods? IMMENSELY. Did it need to be done? ABSOLUTELY.
Any of my close friends will be the first to tell you that I avoid conflict at all costs. However, I pay a lot of money in tuition for this program and a waste of my time is a waste of not only my money, but my intellect and efforts as well. It was the final straw and I now feel better about what has happened as a result. It is fortuitous, I believe, that my group was scheduled with her as our teacher, because we are just outspoken and revolutionary enough to do something about it.
If nothing else, take from this that you need to stick up for yourself, even in the face of embarrassment. Your life will be much more worthwhile if you do. A note of caution though: make sure it is worth standing up for, and if it is at all possible, avoid burning bridges. You never know when that bridge might be useful in the future.
-M
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)